Uncommon insight
Synova on Sep 28 2009 at 3:34 pm | Filed under: Blogs, Domestic Politics, Economics, Libertarianism, Synova's Page, social science
The Saddest Lede on the Internet Today.
Says Ric Locke on his new blog. And what was the lede? “Americans believe that the normal state of things is not-violence.”
Do you suppose that’s true? That that’s why we have such absurdities as people climbing in zoo cages to cuddle the animals? It would explain a lot of things.
The blog article he links goes on to make some sort of argument that the normal state of capitalism is violence and that people should think about why we put up with it…. or something like that.
It’s shocking to me, even though I’m used to the notion, that people do not realize that violence and war are the normal state of things and that civilization is what we impose upon the natural state. (And yes, there are people who seem not to realize that the cuddly animals really will not act all loving and peaceful because they have an uncorrupted ability to tell that you don’t mean harm.)
I think that sometimes libertarians are too convinced that they aren’t talking about imposing order and miss the truth of it, (or at least those opposed to libertarian ideas are convinced that libertarians oppose the imposing of order.) That’s not the difference between libertarian ideas and those ideologies that consider themselves more caring. The difference with libertarian ideas and with capitalism is that those things work as much as possible with the reality of human nature while recognizing what human nature is. Which is violent… just like the rest of nature is violent and unforgiving.
Viewing capitalism as the source of unfairness, vice and violence ignores the truth. Failing to understand the truth of nature and human nature, to face it squarely, means that the proposed cure for social ills will invariably make them far worse. As Ric says:
It would explain, for instance, why the writer of that article is able to regurgitate a century and a half of Socialist propaganda and get commenters calling it “insightful”. Two centuries of modern capitalism have resulted in such ease, such comfort, such near-total safety and security, that Americans (at least, some Americans) don’t just take it for granted but consider it the normal state of affairs, so much so that they are ready and willing to smash the structures that created it, in the confident “knowledge” that the safety and prosperity will remain because they are “normal”.
He’s a smart guy. Check out his blog.
Sphere: Related Content4 Responses to “Uncommon insight”
Trackback URI | Comments RSS
The View From the Bluff: Lance’s Economic and Finance Blog
Thanks for the kind words. FWIW you get a blogroll listing.
Regards,
Ric
We’re doing an interesting book study at church, “Where is God When it Hurts?” by Philip Yancy. In the first part of the book he makes the point that our society has gone out of it’s way to eliminate pain and suffering as much as possible. We have a headache, we grab an aspirin.
A Nobel laureate stated that at 87, he had never seen a person die, nor had he seen a birth.
I think by doing this we alienate ourselves somewhat from the ‘typical’ human experience.
And double thumbs up to what you’ve quoted Synova. Some very good points there.
Whats up guys? yeah we have some smart people on this page. Great subject to. You know you can blog on http://www.women-sunglasses too. Your all invited. Creat your own subjects and get them created for you. But Yeah I really think what you said pretty much naild it in my opinion.
Jason
[...] actually from last week, but too good of a comment not to highlight, even tardily [Via Synova]: Americans believe that the normal state of things is [...]